Toaster Oven Chex Mix has all of the delicious flavor of your favorite snack mix in a small batch recipe! Perfect for small gatherings, gifting, or just eating by the handful.
From these flavor-packed rosemary cashews to a small batch of toaster oven parmesan crisps, one can never have too many savory snack recipes. Especially during the holidays when it’s chocolate and cookies 24/7!
Though I’m happy to eat it year-round, Chex mix is definitely one of my favorite holiday snacks. When I was little, my mom would throw together HUGE batches every Christmas.
They were so big the mixture only fit in a large roasting pan (you know, the kind used to cook a Turkey!).
Since we’re all about small batch around here, I decided to downsize the traditional recipe. That way I could A) make it in our toaster oven and B) avoid eating myself into a salty snack mix coma.
Turns out small was definitely the way to go. My husband and I could not stop snacking on the first test batch and the jar I sent to his office came back empty in just one day!
If you’re looking for a fun snack mix that everyone will love, this toaster oven Chex mix recipe is a guaranteed winner.
Here’s what you’ll need to make it:
- Cereal. We used equal amounts of corn, rice, and wheat Chex cereals. If you don’t like one of the flavors or feel less than thrilled about the idea of storing a bunch of open cereal boxes it’s okay to use only one or two varieties. You just want 3 cups of cereal in total.
- Nuts. I like mixed nuts, some people prefer only peanuts - you do you. For a nut-free option, swap them for cheesy goldfish crackers or plain Cheerios.
- Pretzels. Their salty flavor is a must!
- Bagel Chips. If you can’t find bagel chips (we actually ended up making our own toaster oven bagel chips) you can substitute melba toast, oyster crackers, or just leave them out.
The snack mix coating is a blend of melted butter, Worcestershire Sauce (for a vegetarian version use a vegan Worcestershire sauce - Annie’s brand is very tasty), seasoned salt, garlic powder, and onion powder.
SPICE TIP: we like our Chex mix BOLD with lots of Worcestershire Sauce and seasonings. If you prefer a more mild mix use the smaller measurements provided in the recipe.
How to Make Toaster Oven Chex Mix
Start by combining the cereals, nuts, pretzels, and bagel chips in a large bowl. Then, melt the butter in a small bowl and stir in the Worcestershire sauce, seasoned salt, garlic powder, and onion powder.
Pour the butter mixture over the snack mix and stir well. Like really well. Spend at least a minute making sure all of the pieces get coated.
Next, add the mix to an ungreased pan. I used an old mini roasting pan we got from IKEA but you can use an 11x7 pan. A larger toaster oven sheet pan will also work but I find it’s really hard to stir the mix without getting it everywhere.
Bake the mix in a preheated 250°F toaster oven for 1 hour. You’ll need to stir the pan about every 15 minutes while it cooks.
Don’t try to rush things. Like making toaster oven kale chips, the low and slow cooking is essential for drying out the mix and crisping up everything. Set a timer and pop on a movie or wrap a few presents - the time will pass quicker than you think.
Once the mix looks dry (especially the pretzels, cereal, and bagel chips) it’s ready.
Remove the pan from the toaster oven and spread the snack mix onto a layer of paper towels to cool for about 15 to 20 minutes.
At this point, you may need to leave the room. I always have trouble resisting the urge to snack on the warm pieces!
Are you tired of the dinner routine?
Stuck in a rut or looking for fun new recipes to try?
Our Facebook Group is growing every day! If you haven’t joined yet, we invite you to come check it out and join the fun.
You can ask for recipe ideas, talk about cooking techniques, or get help figuring out the right new pan set for you. If you’ve already joined, invite a friend along!