Skip to Content

9 Fancy Appetizer Recipes To Make For Your Next Party

Looking for a few good fancy appetizer recipes to serve at your next gathering? Here are some of our favorites.

In our neighborhood we have big parties nearly every weekend. Our menu of choice? A spread of fancy appetizer recipes!

To keep the prep work light for whomever is opening their doors to everyone else, the rule of thumb is that everyone brings an appetizer or two to share.

We have a rotation of favorite appetizer recipes, of course, but we also love switching it up and trying new things all of the time.

My favorite kind of appetizer? The ones that are really simple to make, come together in minutes but feel really impressive.

You know the ones. The ones everyone goes crazy for, where the platter is wiped clean, and everyone assumes you’re a culinary genius…but in reality you spent 15 minutes making something.

Ener these fancy appetizer recipes – our favorite appetizer recipes for making a splash with minimal effort! Go forth and knock your friends’ socks off.

1
Cherry Goat Cheese Crostini with Thyme and Almonds Photo
Nora Rusev
Cherry Goat Cheese Crostini with Thyme and Almonds
This simple yet ever so slightly fancy appetizer recipe for cherry and goat cheese crostini with thyme and almonds is an elegant appetizer that will be the highlight of any party. Fresh cherries are pitted and marinated then piled onto toasted baguette that has been smeared with creamy goat cheese. This recipe is wildly easy to make yet endlessly impressive.
Get The Recipe
2
Smoked Salmon Avocado Cream Cheese Pastries Photo
Meghan Yager
Smoked Salmon Avocado Cream Cheese Pastries Recipe
One of our favorite appetizer recipes of all time, these smoked salmon appetizers feature puff pastry tarts topped with homemade avocado cream cheese combined with smoked salmon, fresh herbs, and capers. The combination is fresh yet smokey, with the perfect amount of brine to add the right touch of acidity. The pairing is insanely delicious and these pastries fly off the tray every time.
Get The Recipe
3
Garlic Herb Goat Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms Photo
Nora Rusev
Garlic Herb Goat Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms Recipe
Another of our favorite easy yet fancy appetizer recipes, feast your taste buds on these mushrooms stuffed with goat cheese, garlic and herbs. They come together very easily and are ready to serve in under a half hour from start to finish. When you want to add a little something special to your appetizer line-up, give these earthy, tangy stuffed mushrooms a go.
Get The Recipe
4
Marinated Olives Picture
Emily Caruso
Marinated Olives Recipe
If yours is a crowd of olive lovers, knock their socks off with these citrus and chili marinated olives. They make an incredible addition to your spread of fancy appetizers, or the perfect accompaniment to a cheese board of your favorite charcuterie and cheeses. Toss everything together and these life-changing olives are ready to wow your friends in just about 30 minutes.
Get The Recipe
5
Baked Goat Cheese with Harissa Photo
Emily Caruso
Baked Goat Cheese with Harissa Recipe
Combine tangy goat cheese, cream cheese, spicy harissa, tomatoes and herbs and you’ve officially found your new favorite appetizer. Served with a side of sliced baguette for optimal scooping and dipping, we suggest baking everything in a cast iron skillet for an easy oven-to-table presentation that will impress your most impressive friends.
Get The Recipe
6
Whipped Goat Cheese Photo
Emily Caruso
Whipped Goat Cheese Recipe
Our whipped goat cheese is an easy party appetizer that feels just the right amount of fancy when served with herbed crackers and fresh veggies. Sometimes a few simple, quality ingredients (in this case goat cheese, herbs and honey) outshine far more complicated recipes and this is one of those instances.
Get The Recipe
7
Smoked Salmon Dip Picture
Emily Caruso
Smoked Salmon Dip Recipe
Something about smoked salmon always makes for a fancy appetizer despite what may be a very minimal amount of effort in the kitchen. Enter this smoked salmon dip. Smoked salmon, fresh dill, lemon, capers, horseradish, cream cheese and red onion all merge into one truly flavorful dip recipe. My best suggestion? Double the recipe because it will be gone in no time.
Get The Recipe
8
Garlic Butter Baked Mushrooms Photo
Nora Rusev
Garlic Butter Baked Mushrooms Recipe
Buttery, garlicky baked mushrooms may not scream fancy to you, but somehow they feel like a very fancy appetizer recipe indeed. You can throw this simple recipe together in just a few minutes and the warm garlic butter sauce left behind is pretty epic when mopped up with crusty bread. This is the rustic yet elevated appetizer of your dreams – it also makes a great side dish, too!
Get The Recipe
9
Asparagus and Goat Cheese Tart Picture
Emily Caruso
Goat Cheese Asparagus Tart Recipe
Call anything a “tart” and it automatically sounds very fancy. Use a sheet of frozen puff pastry, top it with a spread of goat cheese, fresh asparagus and finely sliced red onion and you’ve got an appetizer that is worthy of any occasion. Simple appetizers like this are one of the reasons I try to keep frozen puff pastry in my freezer at all times!
Get The Recipe