Skip to Content

13 Sweet Treats Made With Leftover Halloween Candy

Got an abundance of fun sized candy hanging around? Bake it up in one of these sweet recipes sure to please any sweet tooth.

Don’t let that candy go to waste! These recipes are ripe for candy recyling.

1
13 Recipes Using Leftover Halloween Candy
13 Recipes Using Leftover Halloween Candy
Repurpose your fun sized candy with these sweet recipes!
2
Butterfinger Cupcakes Photo
Kristan Roland
Butterfinger Cupcakes Recipe
Use mini Butterfinger bars in these Butterfinger cupcakes, packed with crushed candy in the batter and piled high on top of peanut butter frosting.
Get The Recipe
3
Giant M&M Cookies Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Giant M&M Cookies Recipe
What better way to use M&Ms than in giant, buttery cookies?
Get The Recipe
4
Pioneer Woman Chocolate Cookies Photo
Food Network/The Pioneer Woman
The Pioneer Woman Chocolate Cookies Recipe
Dip The Pioneer Woman’s chocolate cookies in melted almond bark and any leftover candy of your choosing.
Get The Recipe
5
Peanut Butter Cookies Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe
Mini peanut butter cups are right at home nestled in peanut butter cookies.
Get The Recipe
6
Loaded Cookie Bars Photo
Karly Campbell
Cookie Bars Recipe
These gorgeous blondies have a satisfying secret weapon — chopped Snickers bars!
Get The Recipe
7
Rolo Cookie Bars Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Rolo Cookie Bars Recipe
Rolos? YOLO! Bake up a batch of these chewy, caramel-ey cookie bars.
Get The Recipe
8
Monster Cookies Photo
Megan Myers
Monster Cookies Recipe
These cookies are packed with candy and totally versatile, making them perfect for mixing in whatever you’ve got on hand.
Get The Recipe
9
S'mores Pull Apart Bread Photo
Kate Donahue
S’mores Pull Apart Bread Recipe
Mini chocolate bars become gooey, melty perfection in this S’mores Pull Apart Bread.
Get The Recipe
10
Junior Mint Cupcakes Photo
Kristan Roland
Junior Mint Cupcakes Recipe
Junior Mints are the perfect finishing touch on these mint chocolatey cupcakes.
Get The Recipe
11
Heath Bar Cookies Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Heath Bar Cookies Recipe
Heath Bar chunks give these cookies a buttery crunch you’ll love.
Get The Recipe
12
Malt Ball Fudge Photo
Aimee Shugarman
Malt Ball Fudge Recipe
Use halloween candy to make the perfect holiday fudge! You’ll love this creamy, crunchy, malted recipe.
Get The Recipe
13
Butterfinger Cake Photo
Kristy Still
Butterfinger Cake Recipe
This light and creamy cake is a nice change of pace.
Get The Recipe
14
Monster Cookie Dough Truffles Photo
Aimee Shugarman
Monster Cookie Dough Truffles Recipe
These fun truffles are full of candy and cookie dough flavor!
Get The Recipe