Skip to Content

11 Favorite Pie Recipes to Bookmark for Thanksgiving

Looking for a delicious new pie recipe or two? These are all the favorites you should be bookmarking for later.

My youngest was born the week of Thanksgiving and, appropriately, it’s as if she was born with the pie loving gene hardwired into her DNA.

While she loves baking and certainly loves birthday cake, she often asks for pie for dessert on her birthday and who can blame her?

The fall is the perfect time of year to enjoy your favorite pie recipes – especially if you know how to make pie crust like a pro.

These pie recipes are some of our very best and they’re perfect for every occasion from Thanksgiving to, well, birthdays!

1
Peanut Butter Chocolate Mousse Pie Photo
Julianne Bayer
Peanut Butter Chocolate Mousse Pie Recipe
This peanut butter chocolate mousse pie is absolutely mouthwatering. The buttery Oreo crust is filled with a light and fluffy chocolate mousse followed by an easy, silky, peanut butter mousse. It’s amazing to serve on Thanksgiving, but I also gladly serve this decadent pie recipe all year long regardless of season.
Get The Recipe
2
Apple Pie Photo
Stock Art
Betty Crocker Apple Pie
This copycat Betty Crocker Apple Pie recipe produces a golden, flaky crust and a warm, comfort food filling with a delicious hint of spice. It’s perfect served warm on Thanksgiving with a big scoop of ice cream, but it’s also just a perfect pie to make anytime you find yourself craving apple pie.
Get The Recipe
3
Gluten Free Pumpkin Pie Photo
Sharon L.
Gluten Free Pumpkin Pie Recipe
Think of this gluten free pumpkin pie recipe as the perfect classic pumpkin pie recipe but wrapped up in a gluten free crust that will never leave you wanting for anything more. This easy pumpkin pie recipe serves up a delicious creamy filling, crisp pie crust, and warm spices make. This pie is practically perfect.
Get The Recipe
4
Barefoot Contessa Pecan Pie Picture
Barefoot Contessa/Food Network
Barefoot Contessa Pecan Pie Recipe
The fabled Barefoot Contessa pecan pie recipe is the stuff culinary folklore is based on – it is truly the crème de la crème of pecan pie recipes. Our copycat Barefoot Contessa pecan pie recipe is our very favorite pecan pie. Give it a try and it’s quickly going to become your new family favorite!
Get The Recipe
5
No Bake Peanut Butter Marshmallow Pie Photo
Julianne Bayer
No-Bake Peanut Butter Marshmallow Pie Recipe
This no-bake peanut butter marshmallow pie is straight up amazing. Lightly, fluffy peanut butter mousse with an Oreo cookie crust is topped with whipped cream, crushed peanut butter cookies and a peanut butter glaze. If you love a no-bake dessert recipe you need to give this pie a try.
Get The Recipe
6
Banoffee Pie Photo
Janette Fushchi
Banoffee Pie Recipe
This banoffee pie is so called after two of the ingredients’ names combined. Join banana and toffee and you get ‘banoffee’. A graham cracker crust is filled with a layer of sticky toffee, topped with sliced bananas, whipped cream and chocolate shavings. It’s one of our absolute favorite desserts.
Get The Recipe
7
Boozy Chocolate Hazelnut Cream Pie Photo
Susan Palmer
Boozy Chocolate Hazelnut Cream Pie Recipe
There are two types of people in this world. Those who love chocolate and those who do not. I can relate to the chocolate lovers. This boozy chocolate hazelnut cream pie recipe will bring all the chocoholics running from miles away. The combination of chocolate and hazelnuts is simply irresistible!
Get The Recipe
8
Spicy Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Photo
Natalie Paramore
Spicy Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie Recipe
Sweet heat is one my favorite flavor combinations. Whether in a savory dish or dessert, I love contrasting tastes like spicy chocolate and peanut butter! This spicy chocolate peanut butter pie recipe is a serious game changer and a total unique pie recipe to serve up for Thanksgiving or any celebration.
Get The Recipe
9
Layered Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie Photo
Christy Landry
Layered Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie Recipe
Trust me when I say that this layered pumpkin cheesecake pie will make your Thanksgiving dessert spread truly epic. From the Oreo crust to the toffee meringue on top, this thing is mega. It’s packed with endless layers of decadent sweetness and totally changes up the pumpkin pie norm.
Get The Recipe
10
Paleo Chocolate Pecan Tart Photo
Gina Matsoukas
Paula Deen Pecan Pie Recipe
If you have a family that loves a classic pecan pie you need to try this one! This copycat Paula Deen pecan pie recipe is guaranteed to satisfy the entire family. It’s sweet, filling and delicious packing all the standard pecan pie flavors you love and it’s easier to make than you might think.
Get The Recipe
11
No Bake Mocha Fudge Pie Photo
Julianne Bayer
No Bake Mocha Fudge Pie Recipe
Another favorite no-bake pie recipe, this no-bake mocha fudge pie is cool, creamy, and the perfect way to finish out a feast. The combination of the Oreo cookie crust, the light and fluffy mocha mousse filling and ribbons of sweet hot fudge make this pie worthy of a second helping.
Get The Recipe