Instant Pot Mac & Cheese Recipe

Belly-up to a comforting bowl of creamy mouth-watering Instant Pot Mac & Cheese that is made in under 10 minutes. You will never make macaroni and cheese any other way again.

Once again, I’ve been testing and trying different ways to cook macaroni and cheese in the Instant pot, and I’ve finally found the correct heat setting as well as the perfect combo of cheese and cream.

I tested this recipe so many times in one month that my family was only willing to have a few bites toward the end of my testing.

I was handing out containers full of macaroni and cheese to neighbors—no one complained one bit!

People think I’m crazy when I tell them you can actually cook macaroni and cheese in the instant pot.

You place an entire box of elbow macaroni in the Instant Pot plus the spice combo I’ve created, as well as water.

Turn the lid to the locking position and make sure the steam valve is closed. Then set the Instant Pot to “manual” mode for 4 minutes.

That’s it! Easy as that!

It will take about 4-5 minutes to come to pressure. Once the Instant Pot beeps, carefully release the pressure.

You will have a tiny bit of water in the Instant Pot and that is okay. Stir the noodles and then stir in the heavy cream and half the cheddar cheese.

Stir until melted, and then repeat again until all the cheese has been stirred in and melted.

Taste the pasta and add additional salt and pepper if needed. Then ladle into bowls and enjoy.

You can also keep the macaroni and cheese on the “warm” mode and wait to serve it for up to an hour.

However, if you do this you might need to add additional cream.

This recipe is perfect for entertaining with. I can’t wait to create a mac and cheese bar for friends and family this holiday season.

Think about all the fun toppings you can pair with this pasta! My son’s favorite is crispy bacon—yes, that’s how my 4-year-old request his mac and cheese!

During my recipe testing I tried various methods of liquid. From whole milk, heavy cream, and evaporated milk.

At the end of the day my family and I preferred the heavy cream. It yielded the creamiest macaroni and cheese.

Some will argue that if you don’t use evaporated milk, the cheese will clump and coagulate. Yes—that will happen to an extent using the heavy cream; however, we preferred the creaminess.

We found with the evaporated milk it left a little bit of a tangy after taste that we didn’t like. 

When it comes to mac & cheese, the cheese is the second most important component to the recipe.

I tested a variety of cheeses from sharp cheddar, mild cheddar, mozzarella cheese, fontina, smoked gouda, Gruyere, Parmesan and the list goes on.

At the end of the day I really liked the combo of sharp cheddar paired with a mild mozzarella.

I also prefer Cabot cheese of all the cheddars. It’s the smoothest and melts the best.

I’ve grated my own cheddar from a block as well as used the pre-shredded.

I didn’t notice a difference, but every time I tested I used Cabot. So, you might yield different results if you use another brand.

If you’re looking to simplify lunch or dinner, or maybe looking to entertain and make a mac & cheese bar of your own, I hope you’ll give my Instant Pot Mac & Cheese recipe a try.

Are you tired of the dinner routine?

Stuck in a rut or looking for fun new recipes to try?

Our Facebook Group is growing every day! If you haven’t joined yet, we invite you to come check it out and join the fun.

You can ask for recipe ideas, talk about cooking techniques, or get help figuring out the right new pan set for you. If you’ve already joined, invite a friend along!