Skip to Content

Stuffed: 10 Recipes That Are Full of Surprises

Keep your guests guessing with these surprise-inside treats!

What’s the only thing better than dessert?  Two desserts!  Enjoy the best of both worlds with these surprise-inside treats.  Whether it’s candy, frosting, cookies, or even a secret ingredient, there is more to these recipes than meets the eye.

1
Stuffed: 10 Recipes That Are Full of Surprises
Stuffed: 10 Recipes That Are Full of Surprises
Click through for 10 sweet stuffed treats!
2
Oreo Cupcakes Picture
Ashton Swank
Oreo Cupcake Recipe
A whole Oreo cookie awaits you at the bottom of these chocolate cupcakes.
Get The Recipe
3
7Up Cake Photo
Kate Donahue
7Up Cake Recipe
7Up is the secret ingredient in this gorgeous pound cake, resulting in a light and zesty treat!
Get The Recipe
4
Chocolate Rolo Stuffed Cookies
As if chocolate cookies weren’t good enough, Jamie from My Baking Addiction stuffed them with gooey, chocolatey Rolos.
Get The Recipe
5
Biscoff Stuffed Vanilla Bean Snickerdoodles Photo
Alaina Doyle
Biscoff Stuffed Vanilla Bean Snickerdoodles Recipe
Two of my favorites combined! These Vanilla Bean Snickerdoodles are stuffed with irresistible Biscoff spread.
Get The Recipe
6
Hidden Gold Rainbow Cupcakes
My kiddos LOVE finding hidden treasure in the center of these candy-filled cupcakes.
Get The Recipe
7
Root Beer Float Truffles Photo
Aimee Shugarman
Root Beer Float Truffles Recipe
These unsuspecting truffles offer a surprise flavored center — Root Beer Float!
Get The Recipe
8
Peanut Butter Cookies Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies Recipe
A peanut butter cup covered in peanut butter cookie? I’ll take a dozen.
Get The Recipe
9
Cookie Dough Cupcakes Photo
Kate Donahue
Cookie Dough Cupcakes Recipe
These cupcakes are filled with egg-free cookie dough, perfect for curbing those cookie dough cravings.
Get The Recipe
10
Monster Cookie Dough Truffles Photo
Aimee Shugarman
Monster Cookie Dough Truffles Recipe
Candy-filled cookie dough covered in candy? Sign me up.
Get The Recipe
11
Frosting Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies
These frosting stuffed chocolate chip cookies are basically magic.
Get The Recipe