Skip to Content

11 Homemade Treats to Hand Out on Halloween

Don’t settle for the typical Halloween candy. Follow these recipes and give your trick or treaters a personal, homemade treat.

Trick or treat?

How about: trick or HOMEMADE treat?

That’s right, it’s time to show up your neighbors!

It’s time to follow one of the following homemade candy recipes and take your Halloween guests by delicious surprise this year…

1
Monster Cookies Photo
Megan Myers
Monster Cookies Recipe
Monster Cookies combine chocolate, peanut butter, oats and candy in one cookie. A perfect addition to a lunch box!
Get The Recipe
2
Heath Bar Cookies Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Heath Bar Cookies Recipe
Heath Bar Cookies are full of buttery toffee and delicious melty chocolate. Betcha can’t eat just one!
Get The Recipe
3
Rolo Cookie Bars Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Rolo Cookie Bars Recipe
Rolo Cookie Bars are filled with Rolo candies. Chocolate caramel indulgence.
Get The Recipe
4
Nerds Popcorn Photo
Rachel Gurk
Nerds Popcorn Recipe
Nerds popcorn is your new favorite treat, we promise. Studded with your favorite fruity candies, it’s hard to beat.
Get The Recipe
5
Butterfinger Cookie Sandwiches Photo
Rachael Dart
Butterfinger Cookie Sandwiches Recipe
Butterfinger Cookie Sandwiches are heaven for the Butterfinger lover. Two chewy cookies loaded with Butterfinger and a creamy peanut…
Get The Recipe
6
Chocolate Rum Balls Photo
Shanna Schad
Chocolate Rum Balls Recipe
Chocolate Rum Balls will add a hearty kick to your cookie tray. Rum and chocolate cannot be beat!
Get The Recipe
7
Holiday Trail Mix Photo
Sharon L.
Holiday Trail Mix Recipe
Holiday Trail Mix is the perfect snack for your holiday gathering or for on the go snacking. Enjoy a handful anywhere.
Get The Recipe
8
M&M Brownies Photo
Kim Beaulieu
M&M Brownies Recipe
M&M Brownies are a great treat for Easter. So festive!
Get The Recipe
9
Monster Cookie Bars Photo
Jamie Lothridge
Monster Cookie Bars Recipe
Monster Cookie Bars make a tremendous treat any time of day. They’re also great to take along to barbecues and birthday parties.
Get The Recipe
10
Candy Apples Photo
Kim Beaulieu
Candy Apples Recipe
Candy apples are a party treat for Halloween and a delicious dessert throughout fall. Everyone loves them, so get to making your own!
Get The Recipe
11
Almond Joy Bars Photo
Ashton Swank
Almond Joy Recipe
Make Almond Joy Bars at home! Make ’em big or small, and remember that if you skip the almonds, you’ve made homemade Mounds too!
Get The Recipe