Homemade Cookie Crisp Recipe

Homemade Cookie Crisp will remind you of your childhood. And the homemade version is so much better!

Cookie Crisp cereal is pretty much a kid’s dream. Cookies? Sanctioned for breakfast?

If only my mom ever bought them. But the jig was up on that one. We never got to bask in the glow of cookie breakfasts.

Now that I’m a grown-up, I get to decide if chocolate chip cookies are a breakfast item. And I say yes.

Actual breakfast cookies are kind of a thing now. But I want chocolate chip cookies in my cereal bowl.

This homemade Cookie Crisp cereal is not exactly health food. BUT, there is a lot of good stuff in there and less sugar than in not-for-breakfast chocolate chip cookies.

Whereas the original store-bought cereal is fortified with vitamins and minerals, I had to come up with my own way to add those. So coconut oil, wheat germ and flaxseed meal are hiding in this bowl of cookies.

My regular supermarket carries all of those things now, so you shouldn’t need an extra trip. Plus, add some milk (or soy milk or almond milk) and you have even more vitamins and minerals.

Geez, I can talk myself into anything.

And if you’re like my mom and say no to cookies for breakfast, then save this cereal as a treat. Because it’s so so so good.

The coconut oil adds just the right flavor to the dough, and it’s loaded with chocolate chips. Or, forget the cereal part and use the tiny size as portion control for snacking.

Oh, who am I kidding, I ate about twenty before they even got in the cereal bowl.

To make tiny cookies quickly, I use a disposable decorating bag, found in the craft store. Be sure to close the top tightly with a rubber band and cut the opening large enough to accommodate the chocolate chips, about 1-inch.

If you don’t have any decorating bags, I suggest using a freezer-safe (because it’s thicker) gallon size Ziploc bag.

Either of these will save your sanity so you’re not scooping out hundreds of little cookies with a teaspoon. Because we’re piping cookies, it’s best to use the mini chocolate chips, too.

The regular size chocolate chips will overwhelm the decorating bag. And the cookies!

I bake these cookies until golden brown so that when they cool, they are crispy enough to stay crispy in milk. The longer they can stay in the oven, the longer they will stay crunchy in the milk.

That said, they still will get soggy a bit more quickly than store-bought cereal. If you’re a purist with your cookies and milk, you can even serve them in this divided bowl  so the cookies don’t get soggy.

But I’m all about drowning cookies. 

Planning a dinner party and need some inspiration?

How about looking for a new slow cooker dinner idea?

We’ve got you covered in our ever-growing Facebook group! If you’re not a member yet, why not?!

We’re chatting cooking techniques, dessert ideas, and everything in between. If you’re already a member, invite your friends to join us too!